School selection for a son (Saaty 1977)

Fixture school-selection-saaty-1977 from github.com/decisionpoint-io/ahp-verification-fixtures. Judgments from T. L. Saaty, 'A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structures', J. Mathematical Psychology 15, 1977, Tables 10-17.

A public Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) decision built with decisionpoint.io: 6 criteria, 3 alternatives, and 33 pairwise judgments.

Overall ranking

  1. School B — 37.8%
  2. School A — 36.7%
  3. School C — 25.4%

Criteria weights

Overall consistency ratio: 0.07 (within the 0.1 acceptability threshold).

AI-generated summary

Generated by AI from this decision's data; may not reflect the latest judgments.

Results summary

This is a close call between School B and School A, with School B holding only a narrow lead of 1.1 percentage points. The deciding factor is learning, where School B pulls ahead by 14.0 percentage points, and college preparation, where it gains another 5.9 percentage points. These strengths align with the top two priorities in this decision. However, School B comes with real tradeoffs: School A offers notably stronger vocational training and music classes. If your son values those programs or you think they matter more than your current weights suggest, the ranking could easily shift.

Check the sensitivity analysis to see how vulnerable School B's lead is to changes in how much you weight learning and college preparation against the music and vocational options.

Sensitivity summary

A close call, with School B ahead of School A by 1.1 percentage points. This is effectively a two-way contest between School B and School A: almost any meaningful reweighting hands the lead to School A instead. The balance tips toward School A if you lower the weight on Learning (a small adjustment of about 5.6 percent of its current weight), or if you substantially increase the weights on Vocational Training, Music Classes, or College Preparation, or dramatically shift toward School Life.

Decision criteria

Alternatives

With JavaScript enabled, this page shows the full interactive decision: the hierarchy, every pairwise comparison on the Saaty 1–9 scale, consistency checking, the calculated priorities, and sensitivity analysis. New to the method? See What is the Analytic Hierarchy Process?