Selecting a Wheel Loader

A public Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) decision built with decisionpoint.io: 5 criteria, 3 alternatives, and 34 pairwise judgments.

Overall ranking

  1. CATERPILLAR — 42.0%
  2. KOMATSU — 40.1%
  3. VOLVO — 17.9%

Criteria weights

Overall consistency ratio: 0.04 (within the 0.1 acceptability threshold).

AI-generated summary

Generated by AI from this decision's data; may not reflect the latest judgments.

Results summary

Caterpillar edges out Komatsu by a narrow margin of 1.9 percentage points, though this is a close call between the two. Caterpillar's strength lies in Performance, where it holds a substantial 6.2 percentage point advantage. This superiority in performance carries significant weight in the decision, since Performance accounts for 38.9% of the overall evaluation. However, Caterpillar concedes ground on Price and Durability, trailing Komatsu by 2.3 and 1.9 percentage points respectively on those criteria.

The result hinges on whether the performance lead justifies accepting a higher price and slightly lower durability. Check the sensitivity analysis to understand how sensitive this ranking is to changes in the criteria weights, particularly around Performance versus Price.

Sensitivity summary

A close call: CATERPILLAR leads KOMATSU by 1.9 percentage points. The result holds unless weights move substantially on three criteria. Performance is the most vulnerable: reducing its weight from about 38.9% to about 30.3% would hand the lead to KOMATSU. Much larger shifts are needed on Price and Durability, each requiring the weight to move by roughly 50 percentage points or more of its current value, and both would also flip the result to KOMATSU. With four of five criteria showing stable ratings, the current ranking is fairly solid but hinges on whether Performance really should dominate the decision as heavily as the weights now suggest.

Decision criteria

Alternatives

With JavaScript enabled, this page shows the full interactive decision: the hierarchy, every pairwise comparison on the Saaty 1–9 scale, consistency checking, the calculated priorities, and sensitivity analysis. New to the method? See What is the Analytic Hierarchy Process?